Something’s bubbling at Papa Johns, but not the same old pepperoni. With budgets constraining fast-food shoppers and sales flagging, the chain has opted to shake things up with a new aggressive strategy.
But this is not only about crust and cheese — it’s a calculated effort to bring consumers back to the plate. What turned, and why now? Let’s cut into the story and see what’s truly cooking at Papa Johns…
Trouble in Pizza Paradise
Papa Johns has had a rough run. Sales are down, customer habits are shifting, and competitors aren’t slowing down. In the first quarter of 2025, U.S. same-store sales dipped 3% — a red flag in an industry already dealing with rising costs and dwindling loyalty.
The question became clear: how do you keep pizza lovers coming back when everyone’s tightening their wallets?
The Delivery Dilemma
One big culprit? Delivery. Shoppers are backing away from the premium of having food delivered to their doorstep. Many now opt to get their meals to go — or make it at home.
And with inflation pummeling fast food prices, convenience no longer rules — value does now. So Papa Johns realized they needed to rethink the entire customer experience. In came: tech.
Calling in the Cloud
Papa Johns joined forces with Google Cloud in April to fire up its delivery infrastructure. Improved routing for drivers, smarter dispatching, and getting items delivered more precisely were some of the commitments.
It was far from a minor upgrade. It was a tech-driven play to improve the customer experience. But as the back end got smarter, a bit of TLC was due for the front end: the menu.
Time for a Menu Makeover
The competition threat was growing fierce, and winning consumer attention wasn’t getting any easier. Papa Johns tackled this challenge from the bottom: menu fare.
Rather than attempting to ride the next wave or create a gimmick, the brand shone a light on the classics: reintroducing them with more flair. This wasn’t a reimagining; it was a wager on the tastes that customers were already hungry for.
The Return of a Fan Favorite
Topping the list? A big, bold comeback. Shaq-a-Roni — a pizza so big and indulgent it’s named after NBA legend Shaquille O’Neal — is coming back.
First launched in 2020 as a limited-time item, it’s now a mainstay on the menu for $15.99. Loved for its gigantic size and generous toppings, it satisfies nostalgia while providing undeniable bang for your buck.
The Cheddar Revolution Begins
Next up, Papa Johns introduced the Cheddar Crust pizza. It’s a rich, savory twist on their classic pies, starting at $11.99.
With a crust baked in cheddar and garlic seasoning, this new offering is all about texture and bold flavor. It’s designed for those craving something familiar, but just different enough to feel exciting again.
Meet the Cheddar Cheesesticks
To finish, new addition Cheddar Cheesesticks come into the picture. Cheesy sides for $10.50 come complete with Papa John’s signature garlic dipping sauce and rest on a soft dough base smothered in garlic butter and melted cheddar.
These are clearly designed as a limited-time offer to push people’s buttons and bring them back hungry.
Fighting the Flavor Wars
Papa Johns is not alone in revamping its menu. Domino’s introduced Parmesan Stuffed Crust pizza, and Pizza Hut reinstated its popular Cheesy Bites.
Everybody’s vying for a larger piece of the declining pie. These new introductions illustrate that pizza companies are doing more than serve dinner — they’re fighting for existence in a crowded, price-conscious market.
A Market Full of Caution
What’s all the commotion about? People’s eating habits have changed dramatically. Ipsos says that 34% of Americans are dining out at fast food establishments less.
Delivery hasn’t fared much better, with 30% skipping it altogether. Meanwhile, 45% are cooking at home. These changes have forced restaurants like Papa Johns to evolve fast—or face extinction.
The Price of Pizza Loyalty
Fast food prices have soared roughly 47% in the past decade, causing sticker shock even for loyal customers.
People are watching their spending, and pizza — often seen as a treat or weekend splurge — is no longer a sure sell. That’s why offering better value without cutting corners has become the new gold standard.
Strategy Over Stunts
It’s not that Papa Johns is chasing a flash-in-the-pan moment. Rather, it’s backed by data on customer behavior and long-term brand positioning.
In value delivery, refreshing the fan favorites, and upgrading its tech infrastructure, the company takes a layered approach toward winning back trust—and taste buds. This is pizza with a plan.
What’s Next
Will these changes be enough to reverse the sales slump? That remains to be seen. But it’s certainly clear that Papa Johns is willing to evolve.
With permanent menu upgrades, smarter delivery tools, and a renewed focus on customer satisfaction, it’s playing the long game in an industry with short attention spans.
The Final Slice
This menu refresh by Papa Johns is more than a marketing gimmick; it’s a sign of the times. As competition heats up and consumers’ tastes and habits change, only brands that are really listening (and adapting) will stay hot.
Whether the Shaq-a-Roni and Cheddar Cheesesticks will be enough to keep America satisfied is up for debate, but at least for now, the oven’s back on.
Discover more trending stories and Follow us to keep inspiration flowing to your feed!
Craving more home and lifestyle inspiration? Hit Follow to keep the creativity flowing, and let us know your thoughts in the comments below!